Should Canada have been kicked from NC?
•
16 Feb 2009, 11:26
•
Polls
We all now know the story, in their win over Hungary Canada used a merc ( theend). Canadian captain Anim then also merc’d for the USA team in their loss to Slovenia.
ClanBase have made their judgement, banned the Canadian captain and forfeited the match against Hungary. Is this enough?
Should Canada be thrown out of the competition, or was CB right in not reverting to collective punishment?
Related: http://www.crossfire.nu/?x=news&mode=item&id=4343
ClanBase have made their judgement, banned the Canadian captain and forfeited the match against Hungary. Is this enough?
Should Canada be thrown out of the competition, or was CB right in not reverting to collective punishment?
Related: http://www.crossfire.nu/?x=news&mode=item&id=4343
|
44.2 %
(616 votes)
|
|
34.2 %
(477 votes)
|
|
21.6 %
(301 votes)
|
// kick amis because i say so!
I dont see any reasons for kicking out Canada team...
I just dont feel it right, to punish team willing to play, but not having the possibility to because one player isnt avi ... and im sure he got serious reasons like eye cancer of his cat or something, and he really couldnt play
can you be sure they didnt hold a usa passport
Also in my eyes it's the wrong thing to do, but they obviously did offend the rules. The thing that needs to be changed is the rules.
plox inform me as fast as possible
only cro & slo left /o>
This is surely not very encouraging for the scene outside europe :(
anyway, wont help much, i guess anim will just be playing next match, sunday :D
never trusted those cochroaches.
UGH UGH UGH UGH UGH
<3
(please dont make an excuse)
If you actually specced the game you would see they suck.
Once again, dont take it too serious, im just saying.
edit: Yes, both CAN & US should be kicked. If an EC clan let a non-valid person play the whole team is instantly kicked.
Otherwise you can swap persons from the same skill between countries like swapping reload with butchji because they are both very good so where would this end...
RED CARD
YELLOW CARD
http://clanbase.ggl.com/cupcard.php?lid=8339
The worst action gets less penalty... AWESOME.
but they should be playing with canadiens only tbh
Hmm... I wonder who this "Quota" guy is...
The other players were aware that it wasn't allowed as well and chose to play anyway, so they all deserve the same punishment. Kick. Same goes for Team USA.
Rules are rules, if You can't follow them, then step aside, You had wildcard also...why not to use it and play when You have players. Known merc is better than some random US guy....?
Oh another thing: Admins, if You are on the server then tell all the shit BEFORE the game not AFTER that You had this and that wrong. This is because EESTI got yellow card for bff havinng wrong nick and admins couldn't even notice i had wrong guid which i noticed later and fixed on cb page, but instead of giving cards just act ingame. Admins are not spectators to chat in front of hundreds ppl, they have to do things they are there for.
rule violators
and only thing is if they allowed to break that rule i think one rule should be for everyone and made to stick to them rules if not admins not doing there jobs and in cb if a player from another clan merc when not registered with them they would be kicked why not same rule apply just coz are a national team?
Anyway: an Amazing lineus from us http://clanbase.ggl.com/news_league.php?nid=182607&lid=2062 (from ee aswell :o)
BAN
ye and lol at retaliating, your own teammates blew your cover, hf finding out who, if malta cared so much we would have claimed the match to get cancelled since it wasn't played on a gv server :)
E : rulez are rulez, get used to it. its everyday life or pet a dog!
that's cute, just reaffirming the point I was trying to make that euros will do anything to win, hungary lost so they had to point out we were using a smurf, you lost and you were willing to whine about the server, that's how it always is... anything to win right?
And if 1 country let some1 from another country play then other countries would do this too and where will this end?
That's why there is something like a "wildcard', to use it if u don't have 6 persons avi on that day.
Told the people what was what, left the rest to their good judgment - learn the history, had plenty involvement with the NA scene =) I'm fairly neutral on this, not involved in any camp.
As I can see youre not...
Have I any other involvement in this, Hungarian, dislike anim, play CB etc? Nope
Oh, no need for 3rdies trying to justify their ping, it's shit.EOD.