World Cup Officiating

image: landon-donovan

I've been asked to post some more soccer journals after US games, it seems several of you enjoyed reading them, which is good because I enjoy writing them. Obviously, I'm very excited about our result and our upcoming appearance in the round of 16. What makes me even more excited is that by my estimation, Donovan's late goal may be a huge catalyst for the popularity of soccer in the USA and the production of top footballers and world-class international squads. That is something I went into in my last journal and will revisit in the next. For now, I'd like to discuss the questionable-at-best offside that almost denied USA of a deserved berth. While the call in and of itself is upsetting, the trend of terrible calls against the USA that deny us of much-needed goals is downright disturbing.

International sport, and especially the World Cup, has a unique way of unifying the world under something everybody can understand: competition and teamwork. Soccer becomes a universal language for billions, the matches a dialogue between entire nations. It's a free trade of culture, where the poor and meek share 90 minutes with the rich and powerful, and there is an almost supernatural sense of understanding between everybody watching. This harmony is supported by an excellent governing body in FIFA, which I don't think could do a much better job. The booking rules they've put in place for the World Cup encourage friendly play which I think we can all agree is a great idea. However, after almost having two consecutive wins taken away, average Americans can't help but feel like the world is against us. While people are most certainly entitled to their opinion of America, our players and their supporters shouldn't be treated as representatives of our politics. Politics have no place in international sport, nor does one's opinion of a particular nation. It's quite obvious to me, especially from the Slovenia game, that not only do some referees fail to leave their beefs at the door, but some of them may even come in with the intention of helping one side. Of course, that's something completely up to interpretation.

While I'll stop short of suggesting reforms to officiating, I wish there was a review process for referees after a match where a questionable call directly resulting in a score being added or taken away. At the very least, I think an apology from the referee would be in order for some of the more blatant missed calls.

I don't know how to end this and I gotta watch the rest of the Germany vs Ghana match. Discuss and I'll comment.
Comments
30
2 long 2 read!
your right man!
Parent
Soccer Football.
My copy+paste response to football vs. soccer comments:

Americans sound like retards when they call association football "football" since the game we call football (gridiron/American) is by far the most popular sport in our country, whereas soccer is behind football, baseball, basketball, auto racing, and hockey in popularity. Both games were developed separately on different continents after American independence, therefore both games have equal right to the name "football," but gridiron football was being played before association football in America so we call the former "football" and the latter "soccer" to avoid confusion. Ask an Australian what it's like to have the two most popular sports in the country called football.

Also get a life.
Parent
I can't actually believe that there's a possibility that you took me seriously?
Parent
Seems most people are super serious, so yeah :D
Parent
But I'm a friendly person : (
Parent
Football, not soccer
My copy+paste response to football vs. soccer comments:

Americans sound like retards when they call association football "football" since the game we call football (gridiron/American) is by far the most popular sport in our country, whereas soccer is behind football, baseball, basketball, auto racing, and hockey in popularity. Both games were developed separately on different continents after American independence, therefore both games have equal right to the name "football," but gridiron football was being played before association football in America so we call the former "football" and the latter "soccer" to avoid confusion. Ask an Australian what it's like to have the two most popular sports in the country called football.

Also get a life.
Parent
Sorry, I can't get it. Posting as a zombie.
And its still football, not soccer. :P
Parent
My copy+paste response to football vs. soccer comments:

Americans sound like retards when they call association football "football" since the game we call football (gridiron/American) is by far the most popular sport in our country, whereas soccer is behind football, baseball, basketball, auto racing, and hockey in popularity. Both games were developed separately on different continents after American independence, therefore both games have equal right to the name "football," but gridiron football was being played before association football in America so we call the former "football" and the latter "soccer" to avoid confusion. Ask an Australian what it's like to have the two most popular sports in the country called football.

Also get a life.
Parent
Also get the fuck out
Parent
Football instead of soccer
My copy+paste response to football vs. soccer comments:

Americans sound like retards when they call association football "football" since the game we call football (gridiron/American) is by far the most popular sport in our country, whereas soccer is behind football, baseball, basketball, auto racing, and hockey in popularity. Both games were developed separately on different continents after American independence, therefore both games have equal right to the name "football," but gridiron football was being played before association football in America so we call the former "football" and the latter "soccer" to avoid confusion. Ask an Australian what it's like to have the two most popular sports in the country called football.

Also get a life.
Parent
I accept it, but when you write an article, a story to a international website, just use football instead of soccer, because people like me(well, i don't really care,just random flaming) will flame on you.That's my opinion.
Parent
Your second half of your second paragraph can be summed up in one word: paranoia. Some refs are generally poor and you just have to accept it. If you were talking about national championships it would be a different case though.

Also, if you want a positive response on your journals you might want to call the game "football" because that's the actual name of the sport, not "soccer".
My copy+paste response to football vs. soccer comments:

Americans sound like retards when they call association football "football" since the game we call football (gridiron/American) is by far the most popular sport in our country, whereas soccer is behind football, baseball, basketball, auto racing, and hockey in popularity. Both games were developed separately on different continents after American independence, therefore both games have equal right to the name "football," but gridiron football was being played before association football in America so we call the former "football" and the latter "soccer" to avoid confusion. Ask an Australian what it's like to have the two most popular sports in the country called football.

Also get a life.
Parent
You don't read posts, hence you are a moron. Good day to you, sir.
Parent
I appreciate the first paragraph, which I forgot to mention. You have a valid point and like I said it's open to interpretation. I just get tired of the don't call it soccer thing because I post this on my facebook also and I sound like a pompous douche if I call it football there.
Parent
TL;DR FOOTBALL
My copy+paste response to football vs. soccer comments:

Americans sound like retards when they call association football "football" since the game we call football (gridiron/American) is by far the most popular sport in our country, whereas soccer is behind football, baseball, basketball, auto racing, and hockey in popularity. Both games were developed separately on different continents after American independence, therefore both games have equal right to the name "football," but gridiron football was being played before association football in America so we call the former "football" and the latter "soccer" to avoid confusion. Ask an Australian what it's like to have the two most popular sports in the country called football.

Also get a life.
Parent
First look at what you are copying and pasting to me, then tell me to get a life. I surely don't need to use the ancient arguing on the internet image do I :-)
Parent
You have a point but I would have never had to write that if it weren't for the masses of Euros worried about a nickname for a game :D
Parent
Oh no, everybody hates America so they make it hard for us to win but we win anyway and now I am going to whine on the internet so everybody will like us again.

Seriously though. Every team in the history of refereed sports has been disadvantaged at some point. Names like Behrami or Luis Fabiano pop into my head. I know it's bad for you, but mostly just bad luck.
I did say that I was very excited about our results and about making it to the round of 16, but yeah I probably came off as whiny, which I think we're entitled to after almost having our chances at qualifying ripped away. I watch sports all the time, and yes bad calls are part of almost every popular sport. However, most governing bodies and leagues have provisions for reviewing officials after controversial calls, something that FIFA does not have, and I think given the scope of the competition, that would be something more important.

Thank you for a response that was relevant to the article instead of arguing semantics like a 7 year old.
Parent
Well, it's part of FIFA's attempt to keep the sport as free of technology as possible I guess. But they should at least get the best referees in the world in a tournament in which the best players in the world play and let's face it, it's the European and partly South American ones. Someone like Koman Coulibaly from Mali certainly isn't among those and neither is Brazil's Carlos Simon who refereed the Germany game last night but has been dropped out of the Brazilian League for poor decisions two times in advance (though he did a decent job last night).
Parent
Resistance to technology is good, generally, in sports. The only sport that does it right is tennis but that's only because boundaries are so important in that game. However, when you're dealing with a competition of this scope (like you were saying), I think video replays should have some place after the match is over as part of reviewing officials. It's not like FIFA officials don't see them anyways. That might help assure that the best referees are calling the games instead of having guys with whistles in their mouths before a corner.
Parent
It seems to me that part of FIFA's policy concerning referees is to give less renowned ones a chance to act on a bigger stage than their home leagues (also because they've been supervising games almost every weekend plus cups and possible jobs on the side).
Parent
football when speaking to crossfire.

there is always search&replace function even in windows notepad.
Back to top