dylan vs barrett

by aNdr3 • 10 Sep 2010, 13:38 • Journals
first of all, i dont like dylan, okay? anyway i need arguments to prove im right, otherwise my gf will win the debate.. actually the debate is 4 months old but im planning to bring it back again and this time humiliate her for good. basically it is pink floyd vs dylan
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uOokCdkIejk
Comments
58
▼
nicon 10 Sep 2010, 14:44
dylan>floyd, sry bro
▼
niSmO 10 Sep 2010, 17:11
floyd>dylan maaaaaan, get a clue
Parent
▼
nicon 10 Sep 2010, 17:18
pink floyd is far from dylans level
Parent
▼
niSmO 10 Sep 2010, 17:32
please bitch

image: Dark%20Side%20of%20the%20Moon_dark_side
Parent
▼
nicon 10 Sep 2010, 17:32
no
Parent
▼
niSmO 10 Sep 2010, 17:32
ja schwein
Parent
▼
nicon 10 Sep 2010, 17:34
go, play fm hund
Parent
▼
niSmO 10 Sep 2010, 17:36
stop the guilt trip broo, we can get through this
Parent
▼
nicon 10 Sep 2010, 17:45
well is the only possible solution for it
Parent
▼
niSmO 10 Sep 2010, 17:46
nein broo
Parent
▼
nicon 10 Sep 2010, 17:48
homo
Parent
▼
niSmO 10 Sep 2010, 18:04
lets be friends
Parent
▼
nicon 10 Sep 2010, 18:20
no, its over
Parent
▼
niSmO 10 Sep 2010, 18:36
oh maaaan, dont be mad bro
Parent
▼
nicon 10 Sep 2010, 18:47
u mad! i asked you 2 days before i left or so and u were like, ok lets play this asap -.-'
Parent
▼
niSmO 10 Sep 2010, 19:18
but then you went away for like a month and everything changed
Parent
▼
nicon 10 Sep 2010, 19:27
so did my feelings for you
Parent
▼
niSmO 10 Sep 2010, 21:37
you chaaaaanged maaan
Parent
▼
nicon 10 Sep 2010, 23:01
no, im true to myself, you aint
Parent
▼
dualinity 10 Sep 2010, 14:51
no point in arguing with women.
▼
Slasheh 10 Sep 2010, 15:06
cant really compare the two, its like comparing a boxer to a football team as to who is better imo

could compare dylan to neil young tho, who beats him ;) NEIL YOUNG BITCHES.
▼
aNdr3 10 Sep 2010, 15:40
its more like who had a bigger influence
Parent
▼
Slasheh 10 Sep 2010, 15:41
id say dylan had the bigger influence definately.
Parent
▼
aNdr3 10 Sep 2010, 15:52
imho dylan just wasn't too innovative, i believe musicians who later did any experimental music, would say that barrett had a bigger influence. piper at the gates of dawn was quite sensational aswell and gilmour took alot from barrett
Parent
▼
Slasheh 10 Sep 2010, 16:02
Dylan

Other major musicians to have acknowledged Dylan's importance include John Lennon,[304] Paul McCartney,[305] Neil Young,[306][307] Bruce Springsteen,[88] David Bowie,[308] Bryan Ferry,[309] Nick Cave,[310][311] Patti Smith,[312] Syd Barrett,[313] Cat Stevens[314], and Tom Waits.[315]

Pink Floyd

David Bowie,[276] Supertramp,[277] Hawkwind,[278] Queen,[279][280] Blur,[281][282] Kasabian,[283] Massive Attack,[284]The Flaming Lips,[285]Pineapple Thief,[286]Tangerine Dream,[287] The Alan Parsons Project,[288] Kate Bush,[289] Air,[290] The Flower Kings,[291] Nine Inch Nails,[292] Jean-Michel Jarre,[293] Dream Theater,[294] Anathema,[295] Tool,[296][297] Opeth,[298] My Chemical Romance,[299] The Mars Volta, Phish,[300] Coldplay,[301][302]Radiohead,[303][304] Porcupine Tree,[305]The Orb[306], Mostly Autumn,[307]Pure Reason Revolution,[308]Queensrÿche,[309] Pearl Jam,[310] and The Smashing Pumpkins.[311][312]

going from that u could argue floyd were the bigger musical influence as the page credits them with more, but being a huge Nick Cave fan im still backing Dylan ;)
Parent
▼
aNdr3 10 Sep 2010, 17:04
yeah, tbh barrett did tell later, that dylan was an influence to him.. too bad barrett couldnt make more music
Parent
▼
mana 10 Sep 2010, 16:37
you are wrong m8 :< Many bands had taken influence from Floyd but when u start checking who is influenced by who, u get legends like Cave & co who has taken it from Dylan...

Basically i'm sure that Floyd has kinda "bigger" influence, but Dylan has influenced most of the legends who are today @ same position (new bands taking influence from them)

sry for my crap english lol

+ barrett admits himself that Floyd took influences from Dylan so imo thats kinda stupid debate u got going on there m8.
Parent
▼
aNdr3 10 Sep 2010, 17:00
god actually i love all those artists
Parent
▼
mana 10 Sep 2010, 17:02
and basically Dylan has influenced all of those. Dylan was one of the biggest influences for Pink Floyd too. Personally i like Floyd more but in this case Dylan wins.
Parent
▼
aNdr3 10 Sep 2010, 17:05
:( i have to tell my gf that she wins.. going to be an awful day
Parent
▼
mana 10 Sep 2010, 17:06
But Floyd still owns all, only not in this case :)
Parent
▼
huumeantti 10 Sep 2010, 15:24
floyd > dylan, floyd after syd though, syd was bad
▼
mana 10 Sep 2010, 16:43
not in this debate lol

waiting for your reply, i love to debate of music with someone who actually understands about it
Parent
▼
huumeantti 10 Sep 2010, 16:49
what should i reply with
Parent
▼
mana 10 Sep 2010, 16:50
my comment above ur first
Parent
▼
huumeantti 10 Sep 2010, 16:53
i don't really listen to dylan, so i don't know : )
Parent
▼
mana 10 Sep 2010, 16:54
god damn it, was waiting for something uber :< how are u m8? :)
Parent
▼
huumeantti 10 Sep 2010, 16:55
fine, not as fine as i would be if i didn't have a cold though :/
Parent
▼
mana 10 Sep 2010, 16:55
:( u still playing?
Parent
▼
huumeantti 10 Sep 2010, 16:57
raging on public if i'm not playing wow/watching series/outside
Parent
▼
mana 10 Sep 2010, 16:58
k :) have u played LOTRO? it's gonna bee free2play in a week, need to test it.
Parent
▼
huumeantti 10 Sep 2010, 16:59
never played, always wanted to try though, so i might download it
Parent
▼
mana 10 Sep 2010, 17:00
im downloading the free trial atm, i've heard that u can continue f2p after that... let's paly together then!
Parent
▼
huumeantti 10 Sep 2010, 17:01
ok, just remind me some other time, because i cba downloading now
Parent
▼
loazis 10 Sep 2010, 15:49
I think Bob Dylan is just simply amazing, mainly as a lyricist, his way of storytelling is really compelling. O really? Yes really. Ok.
▼
ecklav 10 Sep 2010, 16:49
Bob Dylan is lyrically perfect.
▼
aNdr3 10 Sep 2010, 17:02
i like the childish syd barrett stuff more actually, quite existentialist stuff
Parent
▼
ecklav 11 Sep 2010, 13:57
Bob Dylan's Blues play with your mood like drugs. But that's a personal opinion offc.
Parent
▼
TRNZz 10 Sep 2010, 16:52
basicly pointless debate , comparing folk rock to psychedelia (although most dylan fanbase today are hipster which i hate)
so: shine on you crazy diamond!
▼
mana 10 Sep 2010, 16:56
folk rock -.-' omfg, get ur facts right plz :DDDDDDDd
Parent
▼
TRNZz 10 Sep 2010, 17:02
>-.-'
>omfg
>ur
>plz
>:DDdddddddd

where do i even start. plus he picked up the electric so its folk rock faggot. lol plz !!D;
Parent
▼
mana 10 Sep 2010, 17:04
i not gonna debate with you, it seems pointless.
Parent
▼
TRNZz 10 Sep 2010, 17:06
debating is pointless if you dont have an argument, so its good that you decided to give up now.
Parent
▼
mana 10 Sep 2010, 17:07
check comments above, there's some argument for you.
Parent
▼
TRNZz 10 Sep 2010, 17:16
well you told me , id better back off before i get humiliated
Parent
▼
Snatch 10 Sep 2010, 17:51
1.Pink Floyd
2.Bob Dylan
3.Syd Barret
Back to top