Cathedral!

by nevari • 3 Dec 2006, 13:20 • Journals
Lets try the new competitive cathedral version imo, in 1daycup or smt!
Comments
31
▼
gifty 3 Dec 2006, 13:22
its such a random map, 10000 times too big with all rooms and floors.
▼
nevari 3 Dec 2006, 13:23
The new competitive version is much better, I think we should at least test it, like we tested crevasse and adlernest!
Parent
▼
gifty 3 Dec 2006, 13:24
all those maps you've just mentioned are shit. crevasse is too strange for ET, adlernest too lotto with one 2man kill and way too fast, and cathedral still too huge ;>
Parent
▼
_doNka 3 Dec 2006, 13:47
What the fuck are you on about? He said we should TEST it like we TESTED the other maps, why are you proving they are shit?
Parent
▼
gifty 3 Dec 2006, 14:26
ok, lets test cs_inferno, it might be very cool i've heard!
Parent
▼
_doNka 3 Dec 2006, 14:55
Don't see your logic. Explain Mr. Critic.
Parent
▼
gifty 3 Dec 2006, 15:15
why should we test something if its useless to test. well, ok, i dont mind, do a cup with those maps, but they are just not able to take as a serious map imo
Parent
▼
blushing_bride 3 Dec 2006, 16:08
how do you know if the new version is rubbish until it's tested?

If i remeber correctly old oasis was played for about two years before everyone suddenly realised it was broken. Old goldrush was also played for about two years. There really is no way of knowing if a map is good or bad until its been played many many times. And then once it has been played alot it will be clear what needs changing to make it better.
Parent
▼
_doNka 3 Dec 2006, 17:13
He was speaking about cathedral, you drew the other maps to the convo.
Parent
▼
im a tree 3 Dec 2006, 13:22
cathedral should replace radar, imo

cathedral was designed for competition

radar wasn't
▼
gifty 3 Dec 2006, 13:23
radar is actually the best map existing in ET
Parent
▼
Viax 3 Dec 2006, 13:24
How can a rifle like Radar? ;D
Parent
▼
gifty 3 Dec 2006, 13:25
i also like playing smg, and i think im not the worst in it :B
Parent
▼
stewie 3 Dec 2006, 13:45
Radar is a good map, but I still disagree. It´s not the best and certainly not for 3on3.
Parent
▼
Matias 3 Dec 2006, 13:23
stfu!, radar is ze best map.
Parent
▼
ons 3 Dec 2006, 13:25
the fact that it has been made for competetive gaming doesnt mean its good, while radar is one of the best maps atm
Parent
▼
e1vz 3 Dec 2006, 13:29
idd radar is da best
Parent
▼
_doNka 3 Dec 2006, 14:57
So your only defense here is that it wasn't designed for competition?

Holy fuck, ET wasn't designed for competition, it can't be good!
Parent
▼
Reatard 3 Dec 2006, 13:24
Indoor radar times 2, must be great.
▼
hoho 3 Dec 2006, 13:24
agree, its 10 times better than adlernest or crevasse
▼
Xe0n 3 Dec 2006, 13:29
cathedral is to big. + it's a radar objective copy.
▼
cheasy 3 Dec 2006, 13:32
I agree with you because i have to
▼
Decade 3 Dec 2006, 13:41
It's just another map with too many flat surfaces
▼
blushing_bride 3 Dec 2006, 13:46
the newer version does not have the top floor so its far smaller in terms of playable space then the prevoius version. It always was smaller then GR or radar so i dont see why everyone says its too big! And i would be open to suggestions to improve the map if it were to get properly tested!

http://www.megaupload.com/?d=NS6EZCSV
▼
overdrive 3 Dec 2006, 15:21
The problem with cathedral compared to grush is that it isnt linear. As i remember the map it has so many routes that it was a real pain in the ass to make decent tax for it. Grush is just far easier to play because everybody will be busy defending the tank, rather then a spawnflag, 3-4 routes, plantable doors, etc. Just way to much possiblities. Removing the top floor might have reduced the problem, maybe its time to check out the map again.
Parent
▼
blushing_bride 3 Dec 2006, 15:59
Axis only need to defend the floor area now.
Parent
▼
blushing_bride 3 Dec 2006, 13:50
radar is the best map ever though and should never be replaced!
▼
_doNka 3 Dec 2006, 14:59
Del | **** | Reply

I'm sure there is a cool thing between Del and Reply!
Parent
Back to top