PL vs EE scandal?
•
26 Apr 2010, 23:40
•
Journals
After reading through the rules of CB i found following statements:
7
# Nationality and residence requirements:
* Captains must have the nationality and be residents of their team's country. The supervisor can make an exception if there is no candidate who meets these requirements.
* Players who have the nationality of the country they live in are always allowed to play for that country.
* Players who have the nationality of another country than the one they live in:
o Can play for their home country without any further requirements. However a national team may never have more than two such players playing at the same time. This means entire teams of ex-pats (players living abroad) are not allowed.
o Can play for the country they live in if they've lived there for more than 1 year. However a national team may never have more than one such player playing at the same time.
o May never play for more than one country during the same season.
* A player with two nationalities can only play for one of them.
o If he lives in country A he can play for country A without further obligations.
o If he lives in country A he can play for country B after showing a valid legal document to prove that they have the nationality of country B (just having the right to obtain such a document is not enough).
o If he has already played for one of the two countries in the past, he can not play for any other country.
o Any player, who legitimately (according to ClanBase rules) played for a country, can play for it in future NationsCups and for it only.
# When players are in multiple clans, they are classed as clan mates, with all of their coresponding clans.
# Any team found violating this rule will forfeit the match the offence was committed in.
# If a national team does not have enough players to play the match (e.g they only have 4 players available for a 5v5) they must use their wildcard before the scheduled match time or they forfeit the match. National teams are not allowed to play matches with less than the required number of players.
Shouldn't i see a forfeit win for PL because of breaking these rules?
Only need some decent reply from a CB admin thx :D
Kind regards,
7
# Nationality and residence requirements:
* Captains must have the nationality and be residents of their team's country. The supervisor can make an exception if there is no candidate who meets these requirements.
* Players who have the nationality of the country they live in are always allowed to play for that country.
* Players who have the nationality of another country than the one they live in:
o Can play for their home country without any further requirements. However a national team may never have more than two such players playing at the same time. This means entire teams of ex-pats (players living abroad) are not allowed.
o Can play for the country they live in if they've lived there for more than 1 year. However a national team may never have more than one such player playing at the same time.
o May never play for more than one country during the same season.
* A player with two nationalities can only play for one of them.
o If he lives in country A he can play for country A without further obligations.
o If he lives in country A he can play for country B after showing a valid legal document to prove that they have the nationality of country B (just having the right to obtain such a document is not enough).
o If he has already played for one of the two countries in the past, he can not play for any other country.
o Any player, who legitimately (according to ClanBase rules) played for a country, can play for it in future NationsCups and for it only.
# When players are in multiple clans, they are classed as clan mates, with all of their coresponding clans.
# Any team found violating this rule will forfeit the match the offence was committed in.
# If a national team does not have enough players to play the match (e.g they only have 4 players available for a 5v5) they must use their wildcard before the scheduled match time or they forfeit the match. National teams are not allowed to play matches with less than the required number of players.
Shouldn't i see a forfeit win for PL because of breaking these rules?
Only need some decent reply from a CB admin thx :D
Kind regards,
:_D___DDD
so stupid
Quote Clanbase:
[/b]
PL must get the win
EE failed :/
but getting poland out of the way does sound good
fuck poland.
e: Precedent was set with removing the NA teams/players when they did this, rules should apply the same to EE and nordan. Would have been one thing if they were upfront about it, but it's another to smurf and have the rest of the team knowingly play with a fake-nicked player.
first, there was suggested to REPLAY the entire war, and PL declined this (i agree with them, why wud they wanna replay)
noone ever said smth bout winning the match, admins only said smth bout getting the win of the map
and thats what PL did, they accepted the win of the map (noone said anything bout the entire match ...)
so please, if u talk, make sure u know what ur talking bout :)
maybe next time allow using cheats in game if both teams agree!
At least that's what happened to the NA teams and Anim + The_End.
haha nerds
how much $$ you got for it?
big grief for admins .... but this is KB !! yuupi :|
it's not like poland complained and demanded a forfeit win after they found out is it?(and if we were talking a OC/EC game you would have to check guides and fakenicks yourself BEFORE the game started to claim on the freelancing rule, sure last NC season a couple of yellow cards were handed out for fakenicking, and that without any protruding new rules, but never else.)
so if we are to follow up with the crossfire standard, opinion equals fact:
PL got a free win on EE's strongest map.
PL could aswell have selfkilled on max every spawn on adlernest where they couldnt put up the most wimpish resistance.
PL couldn't put up any resistance on supply as well, giving away the fastest time on supply as of yet in this NC.
that means PL did not deserve to get any further, since they are way weaker than EE.
by crossfire logic, luck is an flawed aspect of advancement, and because we can conclude that EE is stronger than PL, the game did not realy have to play out further than showing that EE realy is stronger than PL.
you can read, i can read: if u read the rules and answer following question:
did EE break the rules and do rules state PL shud get forfeit win?
u shud know the answer by reading up my post :)