Should the Netherlands & Finland be kicked from NC?
•
9 Mar 2009, 14:25
•
Polls
Following the Croatia fiasco, frozz has raised questions of the Netherlands and Finnish teams for this seasons NC. Should the same rules apply, and both favourites be kicked?
|
|
54.9 %
(969 votes)
|
|
|
45.1 %
(797 votes)
|
Read them next time, and change them for next NC.
Its like forfeit some teams at ETMASTERS because they used a 180º script. Is it worth the redcard/ban? No its not, but rules are clear. A yellow card would be fair instead. Kick = 2 yellow card or 1 red card (180º isnt red card worthy)
But at the other side 180° scripts are clearly bug abusing, like hardly defusable bugplants would be so it´s justified I guess. A bug is a bug, doesn´t matter how much advantage you gain from it imho.
speaking the truth?
Not nice of you telling us/me lies:C
and RULES ARE RULES is clearly stupid, people should use their brain sometimes .
I dont agree with the 3v3 thing cuz it's not 6v6 competition
on the other hand, why did clanbase not warn or advise all teams about this and not wait till soooooo many games had been played before enforcing the rule? surely they must check these rosters before the competition actually starts? if not, its the hieght of lazy adminning and they need a shake up in who runs CB. they could have spotted the roster rule breaking before it even started and surely this could all have been avoided?
but rules are rules !
The rule only excist to stop countries from getting a head start over other countries because those players are used to each other (I think) but if it goes so far to force countries to play with far less skilled players it just isnt a nations cup anymore.
I don't rly understand you guys, that always was a well know rule, what did you expect? Players now have bigger ego so they think they are god like, but NO, rules are rules. In past nobody had problem with it, now it's a big THING because it comes to the " stars " and " wnbs "
OR
bb fin and nl too :>
ye sure cortana's NC lineup is the same as their normal lineup, what do you expect, they should take random low noobs from their nation so they can lose all matches?
They’ve retrospectively issued cards to teams for not having the correct names in-game, even though a ref was on server & didn’t enforce it – see no reason why they couldn’t.
what happened to croatia btw?
they should have checked it all before the cup started.
we players can always do mistakes, but the rule makers should check if all teams were correct, thats their mistake
Im sure the admins want the cup to be as good as possible but with that rule your not allowing some very good players to compete, which means its not going to be as good as it could be.
but
i dont understand why all those retarded polls
its not for us to decide
if cb kick fin and nl so good for them
if not, they must bring Croatia back and update their rules
Community pressure o/ something about bums & opinoins, burp
slob on my knob you mug
It's a saying, "opinions are like arseholes, everyone has one".
was rly awsome movie :D
ARSE :~>
he was like why he didnt punch back
why no one helped him
HE SHOULDNT DIE!!
oh didnt see that one comin
useless dweeb
I think the 3 players from a team rule is pretty good though. You see players that wouldn't normally playing together doing so, making it a bit more interesting to watch.
Let's see what CB will do.
Eurocup invites were BS
Nationscup rules are BS
Maplists are BS
but np we are used to it :)
ANYWAY i still love ET cuz of the friendships and i still manage to have fun playing :)
fully agree with you tanQie <3
clanbase is going mental!
Just too bad I clicked yes without studying the case (because of the rules are rules thing), but now that I noticed what's it about I almost fell down from my chair xD
Defix is a 3on3 team so how could we have more than 3 players from same team :D ?
And in addition to that, defix nearly never plays without me and Sanda both in the field. Ofc one of those guys has been 3rd often, but they never played at same time...
but well, if this is what komar meant with "UK in the playoffs", well kinda pathetic thing if it really happens
at least according to cb
afaik like every german nc guy is in there as well as a lot more guys too
'cause it's wasted time :)
:--D----G----C
if not - kick both
fck it and let them both play ;D
but, as it was stated, rules are rules, so if you hurt one team, do it to the rest, unless you explain why these cases differ from the croatian one.
CRO banned = FIN NL (POL) banned !
Ban 'em all!
the whole rule is crap, considering that croatia only got like 10 decent players or so, almost all of them playing in the same team.
Though, I can't understand why they would kick Croatia from NC anyway. It's insane that you kick a team while a few of their players didn't play in EC.
Same counts for NL, tekoa played active with impact for the last few months. Before that he didn't play a single official with us (dnan).
You seriously have to leave all your ex-clans?
E: nvm
No though ;D
All 3 cases are ridiculous.
Couldnt care less for nl and fin though, there are plenty of good fins and nl players out there to choose from, they all know the rule. Any1 saying he never heard of this rule hasnt been around very long.
Only solution for this would be that let all those countries, which would ment another big joke and another glim of shame for CB,but ET ain't that big competitive game anymore that we should allow consciously them to deny our best player to play, which obviously is a fatal mistake and it shows CB's inability to admit their own mistakes.
Vote for no, John Adams for president.
And it's a bullshit rule which should be scrapped.
It's good tho that not only CRO is punished. It's all 3 of them or no one.
Latvia for playoff !!!
BTW. 3 clan members per team also sux. Imagine national teams(football e.g.) that are forbidden to use best players from some club because there is a rule they can use only 5 of them at the same time. In croatian handball, we have had a same coach for our best club and our national team. More than a half played in our national team.
Not to mention that croatia has 8 active et players playing on a decent(skilled) level. (Cortana+danl&drvac)
Do offer your learned phraseology.
Not my fault if people can’t think for themselves :x
ex:
how many hours do you spend on your pc every day:
30 mins
45 mins
60 mins
90 mins
120 mins
most ppl will pick 60 mins as it looks like the social norm =)
etc etc
Assuming your intention and after reading some of your topics why would you assume the rules aught to be changed just because it involves favourites breaking the rules? A captain is obliged to know the clan history of each player. The rules are clear and so this whole poll is completely useless.
clan memberships are not associated to nation's teams memberships imo
KICK BOTH TEAMS,THX.
It brings back some superb memories. Thanks :)
(but what did they do? did the nl team play under the influence of mary jane :) )