Italy, Greece, Portugal, (Ireland?)

Let's have a political discussion, what shall we do with them? Another crisis incoming? Share your expert opinions!
Comments
83
remove them from the EU!
They have done nothing wrong, it is just a jew-organized conspiracy against catholics.
Nothing to do, we are all going to bankrupt. Sooner or later.
Or just change the society system. Get rid of money-->get rid of problems. How to do it? Don't ask me.
HOORAY FOR TRADING!

I'm in.
Parent
i will give you 1kg of sirloin steak for that hard drive
Parent
get rid of money => every rich person that doesnt own much stuff (except for green bills) gets fucked in the butt :D ! i likey

boem g5'd
Parent
Doesnt matter what you do with them anymore, it will effect all Europe massivly anyway, especially if you kick them out ^.^
Some estonian bank-guy said, that euro should have 2 currencies in the future, one for the southern countries and another for northen. :D
Parent
the lattern only because the banks are going to lose one hell of an amount of money if you ditch those countries... and the countries those banks are situated in 'have to' save those banks.
Parent
im not sure what would help to make the world better :/
another world war perhaps?
Parent
no i dont like war
Parent
it would help though
Parent
help who?!

war is never good imo. !
Parent
not good in a 'moral' point of view maybe, but still very good considering economy. (for the winning side only obviously)

but has a positive economical effect for the losing party too. they get rid of any depts. of any social standards too most likely but see it as a new beginning, economy rockets up after any way (true, it hits rock bottom first...but it rises steeply) :P
Parent
but has a positive economical effect for the losing party too

proof it on countries who lost wars.
Parent
take germany for example. our economy was at it's lowest at the end of ww2 (practically because everything was being bombed). and look how it evolved until today, it's at it's highest... ever

(that line was not to be taken seriously. it was meant to mock economics itself. an uprise trend is always preferable, and thats what you have after you reach zero, there's no other way.)
Parent
true, a bad but effective way
Parent
do not care - let germany have it's own currency again and switch all jobs from production and sales into service providers and import again - case closed :P
hopefully your not serious :O
Parent
obviously not^^

but that would be the only possible solution for germany to even get out of the euro again and yet not have a major inclination in it's economic system IMO (that it is not realisable, since you won't get everyone within a day to switch jobs and do something else (and be successful at it) is for certain) :DD
Parent
:D
the major upcoming problem of leavin euro and getting a new own currency would rather be the upward revaluation of this currency.. in fact we could import things pretty cheap. but we are mainly an export nation - tho exporting goods would become drastically more expensive for other countries, which in the end will lead to a shrinking economy here :/

basically everything is shit ;D seems like there has to be found a way to solve the problems as good as possible in this system we are currently running in :S

or as sac stated... lets start new world war
Parent
yes - currently we depend on exports, well thats why i said - let's switch back to import (having the upward revaluation of our current currency in mind) and switch all export related jobs to import and service providing(since that could still be somewhat exported^^)...but yes, not a real option I'm afraid

but neither is war, I'm sorry, at least not for 'us'. we'd get smashed big times. just let the US and...china for example have war. might have a positive effect not on national but on world economy at least maybe :P
Parent
basically the idea aint that bad.. mercedes and audi for every yerman :-D and the rest can become farmers :XD
and ye we prolly would get rolled hard by bangladesh or any other poor country in the world ^^
Parent
its funny america has more dept per person than they have in greece
the EU is trying to save greece but america is worse & no1 is doin shit there :)
maybe because the EU is not responsible for the US? ;)
(not to mention that they're by far beyond salvation)
Parent
ye no ofc the EU isnt responsible :p
but the US itself is doin shit & it basicly started there
Parent
it's not like the US being bankrupt would do any less damage to us..
Parent
yea well, low $ results in a high €, but only as long as they use the $ for international trades. as soon as they dump it it shouldn't have any impact on us anymore (IF there is one to substitude for the lack of goods and services...and to buy ours)
Parent
Well, what can i say, america is america, its basically a country with two worlds living in it, one is megapoor which they hide, and the another megarich side lives in hollywood and get ridiculously much money for doing nothing
Parent
thats the american dream...
Parent
no the american dream is that poor people do all the work your ment to do and you get mega rich off of it.
Parent
the american dream was designed to keep poor people quiet, so they dont start a riot against the system of the rich. ":D"
Parent
Like Japan whit a debit 225.8% bigger then the pil, don't know why no one talk about this.
Parent
japan is still recovering from the tsunami
Parent
the data it's before the tsunami
Parent
Because most of that debt is towards their own citizens which means the money stays within the country. There's not a flow of money out of the country to foreign investors unlike Greece. If needed, Japan can increase taxes if the problem becomes precarious. Also, because most of the debt is in domestic hands, foreigners don't have a big impact in speculating against it.

Secondly, Japan has a very low private debt (the japanese people barely have any personal debt) which means they can more easily handle a higher public debt ratio.

Thirdly, Japan's economy is in a better shape (allthough not that great either) then Greece, Italy, Portugal or Ireland.

And last but not least, Japan has a very big economy which means the tax base is much larger then Greece or Portugal. If they get in trouble, they can more easily raise taxes to fulfil their financial obligations (eg. finance their debt).
Parent
How can a state have a debt toward their own citizien when the debt it's of all the citiziens?
japan hasn't a very low private debt to me,italian private debt it's lower then japan.
Parent
guess he means japanese obligations are more related to japanes banks and donors. so most credits are are given and paid from japan in japan. besides that greece has most of its olbigations on foreign banks or creditors.
private debts are another story.
Parent
What's so difficult to understand about it? :)

Japan (the government that is) has a public debt of 225% so let's say a 10 trillion $ public debt. Because japanese save a lot, they buy japanese bunds. As far as I know, a huge majority of those bunds (90%??) are in japanese hands. Basically the government has 10 trillion $ debt which is in the hands of the japanese people themselves.

Italy has one of the lowest levels of private debt in the west but Japan aswell has a quite low private debt compared to the rest of the western world (indeed not as low as Italy afaik).
Parent
Italians save a lot too, probably the most in europe. Italians have owned homes more then in other states in europe. Why no care about private debt? for example UK have a really big private debt.
Parent
Because a dozens of economic paramters are used, not only public debt and/or private debt.

The problem for Italy is the lack of growth. Italy's economy grew at the lowest pace of all EU members in the last 10 years. Without growth, you can't pay down your debt and your debt burden becomes too big. Also, reforms in the labour market are urgently needed in Italy. Without these, economic growth will be even harder to achieve especially with the population becoming older, costs will increase, etc...

The fact is Italy has the 2nd highest public debt (120%) in the EU, a deficit of 4,5% which means Italy's debt becomes bigger every year. Add in the fact that Italy barely grows at all, you know why investors are questioning Italy's ability to pay down their debt. Also, Italy has a quite high tax rate alreaydy so it's harder to raise taxes even more which means there's less room to get money from the citizens to pay for the increasing debt.

The difference with the UK is that the UK has a growing economy, public debt is a lot lower (80%) then Italy's and they have more room to increase taxes, have a more dynamic economy,etc... but yes the UK has it's problems aswell, just not enough for investors to question their ability to pay down their debt.
Parent
The € was fundamentally flawed from the beginning as there were no mechanisms put in place to sustain or help individual countries that got into trouble.

A single interest rate across hugely divergent economies as well as population sizes proved a disaster for Ireland in particular.

It allowed a corrupt government(almost Berlusconi levels of corruption) to allow income tax revenues to fall below what was needed and replace that revenue with stamp duty on new houses, along with insane tax breaks for developers. When the inevitable construction crash came, well we all know what happened then.

No idea why I wrote all that tbh
with germany being one of the biggest countries of the € zone i wonder how you can wonder about the lack of such mechanisms such as saving 'declining' countries. it surves the purpose why "we" are in the € in the first place
Parent
Quote by SsAPI wonder how you can wonder


image: vk_Tovenaar
Parent
It's all part of the plan to control Europe financially?
Parent
nono, bad economics in the euro zone keeps the euro low, which is good for exports, that's why 'we' are up for it, that's what we do for a living
(well not I, but germany)
Parent
nuke them all.
I wanted to comment that :(
Parent
Ask the motherfucking rating agencies to stop downgrading the mark of Greece, Spain, etc. They are just speculating and making the things going even worse...
+1 Those rating companies are a joke, no transparency, no regulation
Parent
agree, it's incredible that these agencies can decide the future of a nation
Parent
I blame rochechild
end of capitalism? :-)
image: Hugo+CHAVEZ this guy knows the solution
snooze they lose, cannot help the weak... :(
YOU ALL SHALL GIVE US MONEY. THAT'S WHY WE ARE IN EU
Oh well, who gives a shit anyway?
My country went bankrupt, and it's almost chaos everywhere, still, I'm a rich sob and I don't give a flying fuck.
Unless you are poor like your government, I don't see why you should care.
So you don't care about rising taxes? I see your only 17 so you don't care if you don't find a job and if you find one, you don't care you'll earn less and/or pay higher taxes on it? You say your rich, maybe the portuguese government will create a wealth tax, who knows? It's more likely to happen in a country that is broke then in a wealthy country :)
If you have a few 100k euro or a few million, no, you shouldn't have a problem but otherwise I think you should :)
Parent
If you have a few 100k euro or a few million, no, you shouldn't have a problem

I don't have a problem ma boi.
Parent
LoL, are you in the drugs industry or what? How do u have so much money? Or is it your parents who have it?
Parent
Youuuuuu don't ask miii about maa bsns.
It's srsbsns.
Parent
Obvious answer from a 17 year old portuguese boy who doesnt know shit about life :)
Parent
But has some money in his pocket and doesn't give a shit about the rest =)
Parent
You do realize that money value decreases if your country keeps failing like this :D?
Parent
You do realize we use the euro currency.
Parent
You do realize that you are a moron?
Parent
Yes and that's why you are not outside spending your money, going to the beach, getting some drinks and chicks instead you spam here on crossfire, awesome way of being a rich guy :)
Parent
1) I don't go to the beach because I'm a nigger, don't need to get tanned.
2)I'm very healthy, I don't drink alcohol.
3)I'm gay, don't need chicks.
4) How am I spending money by spamming cf?
Parent
image: Explosion-nuke

Survivors ->

image: ar5t
there is salary overcharge over all europe during too many years, while in china exports liek a bitch, the piigs can go out of euro but they import you know?
like pumu already said, it is just another social order failing... like communism or monarchism did ... not capitalism is going down imo.

upcoming social order for the next few decades will be some environmental saving shit or something like that imo... those are the last breaths of capitalism.
Back to top